Once stung, twice (as) paranoid.

If Im already dreading it, has she already won?

Also scary: first dates!

Image

Credit: Tina Rowden/Fox

Their sting induces a growing state of paranoia that leads to madness and, eventually, death.

The Red Ladys first two victims are the judge and the head of the PTA (Acronyms, lef-tenant!

), but shes coming for a third: Reynolds.

Hes been stung by the time he gets to the second crime scene, and its already taking effect.

Hes also pretty insecure about that roommate of hers.

And today in Obligatory Betsy Ross Tie-Ins: This has happened before.

(Couldnt Grace do that?

I want this for her.)

But the tonic helped save Washingtons life, too, and theyll need it to keep Reynolds alive.

For ingredients, Jenny takes Joe to a Trinidadian medicine shop to meet up with a friend.

Possessed by a demon with a very tight grip, he warns that shes going to be claimed.

Watch yourself, sis, Azzaca says when the possession is broken.

Your fate has changed.

He asks Joe to protect Jenny, and I check my apartment for wasps, because Im getting paranoid.

Shes hell bent on putting that life behind her, but Reynolds hasnt let it go.

Then again, she doesnt have to save the world in a day.

Let the beautiful people hook up.

NEXT: Will you accept this rose?

IfSleepy Hollowwere a mockumentary, this is the part where Crane would look directly into the camera.

The Red Lady already succeeded in turning paranoia into a weapon.

Elsewhere in foreboding plot developments, Jenny and Joe arent great at following orders.

He calls Nevins to arrange a meeting, handing over the Shard in exchange for information.

Nevins says that Corbin was drawn to darkness and power, and he sees that same instinct in Joe.

But you cant turn Joe Corbin that easily; he brought Jenny as backup.

Here we go right back down the possessed friend changes sides path that weve walked every season already.

Will the Mills sisters ever catch a break?